A hooded man stands under a streetlight with one hand clamped over his mouth, blood running between his fingers, and when the hand finally comes away the face underneath is not the one he walked in with. That is the last real image in the final trailer for “Clayface”, and it is the first time DC Studios has shown Matt Hagen doing the thing the character is named for. Warner Bros. put the trailer out on September 24th. It runs a little under a hundred seconds, and it closes on a card that says the film is in theaters October 23rd, which by the trailer’s own count is four weeks away.
The story has not changed since the summer, and the trailer does not pretend otherwise. Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries) is a Gotham street kid turned movie star whose face is carved up in an attack, and Dr. Caitlin Corr (Naomi Ackie) offers him an experimental treatment that gives the face back and takes a good deal more than that in return. What is new is how much further the footage is willing to go, and how carefully it still stops short. Warning beyond this point there are spoilers for “Clayface” and for the new footage in its final trailer.
That is the last real image in the final trailer for “Clayface”, and it is the first time DC Studios has shown Matt Hagen doing the thing the character is named for.”
The trailer opens somewhere unexpected, on Hagen at the edge of a turquoise sea, letting wet sand run out of his fist, and then cuts to a steel dish of something brown and glistening that is plainly not sand. From there it moves fast. We get the clinic, with Corr asking “What do you want, Mr. Hagen?” and Hagen answering “I want my life back.” We get the attack itself, a man pinned to a bed while someone holds his head still, then the bandaged ruin of a face on a hospital pillow, then a syringe going into a cheek under violet light. Corr’s line a few beats later, “You have to learn to control it”, is doing more work than it seems, because the rest of the trailer is about a man who cannot.
Most of the middle stretch is footage we have seen before, and it is worth being honest about that. The airplane sequence is back, Hagen in a window seat under the cabin’s blue light, pressing his palms into his eyes, then locked in the lavatory with a pair of small scissors held up to his own face. The premiere looks familiar too, Hagen in a dark suit working a crowd outside a theater, a woman in a gold dress at his shoulder, flashbulbs going off like a strobe. If you watched the July trailer, the first minute here will feel like a recap, and it might be designed that way, a reminder for the audience that only catches trailers in front of other movies.
The new material starts with a conversation and a detective. Detective John Borelli (Max Minghella) stands in a lamplit office looking like a man who has been asked to believe something ridiculous, and Corr tells him, in so many words, “This is going to be hard for you to believe. Matt Hagen can change his face.” It is a short exchange. It matters more than any single effect in the trailer, because it tells us the film is going to spend time on the people around Hagen trying to understand what he is, rather than simply cutting from one transformation to the next. Hagen’s own answer to all of this, somewhere later in the cut, is a quiet “Is that so bad?”, followed almost immediately by somebody screaming.
The second new beat is the one fans have been circling since the trailer landed, and it is shot so that you are not sure what you are looking at. Hagen pulls someone in a cream sweater into a hug in a warm, lamplit room, and when the camera drops to their hands on his back, his back gives way under their fingers, the fabric and whatever is beneath it folding around them as if they are sinking into wet clay. The next shot is Hagen’s face, crying. Gizmodo read it as Hagen pushing a person into his own body, and that is the likeliest reading, though it is a guess from a few frames, and Warner Bros. has not described the scene anywhere. Then comes the streetlight shot, the hand over the mouth, and a stranger’s face giving way to Hagen’s own.
What the trailer still refuses to show is Clayface. There is no full creature, no hulking mass of clay, not even a clean look at Hagen mid-change, and that restraint now feels deliberate rather than accidental, because this is the third piece of marketing to hold the same line after April’s teaser and the July trailer. Harries has hinted in interviews that the final form is worth waiting for, and his enthusiasm for it is hard to miss, but DC is betting that a monster you have not seen is scarier on opening night than one that has already been turned into a thumbnail. It is a risk, and it is the right one for a horror film, even if it probably costs them a few clicks in the meantime.
The look of the thing is where you can feel the people behind the camera. James Watkins, who directed “Eden Lake”, “The Woman in Black” and the 2024 remake of “Speak No Evil”, has made a career out of dread that builds in ordinary rooms, and the trailer’s best shots are ordinary rooms made wrong: a clinic with the blinds half drawn, an airplane toilet, a basement corridor soaked in red light. Rob Hardy, whose photography on “Ex Machina”, “Annihilation” and “Civil War” leaned on clean surfaces and sudden violence, shot it, and the palette swings between that cold turquoise, sodium orange streets and a red that arrives whenever Hagen loses control.
The script has its own lineage. Mike Flanagan, the writer behind “The Haunting of Hill House” and “Midnight Mass”, wrote the original draft, and Hossein Amini, who adapted “The Wings of the Dove” and wrote “Drive”, is credited alongside him. Flanagan’s horror has always been about grief more than gore, and you can hear it in the trailer’s quietest line, “I have no idea who you are anymore”, which sounds less like a threat than a eulogy for someone who is still standing in the room. Volker Bertelmann, who won an Oscar for “All Quiet on the Western Front”, wrote the score, and in the trailer it is mostly low pulses and silence that the screaming cuts straight through.
The business around the film has shifted since the cameras stopped rolling in Liverpool. “Clayface” was first dated for September 11th, and in February Warner Bros. moved it to October 23rd so it could open in the run-up to Halloween, which is exactly where a $40 million horror picture wants to be. Earlier this month the MPA rated it R for strong bloody violence, gore, language, some nudity and brief drug use, which makes it the first film in James Gunn and Peter Safran’s DC Universe to carry an R. The runtime has been reported as 108 minutes, lean by comic-book standards and about right for the genre it is actually in.
That positioning is the interesting studio call. DC could have sold this as a Batman spinoff, and there are small Gotham touches in the footage, a skyline across the water and an American flag snapping over the river, but not one frame leans on the Bat. Instead it is marketed like a Blumhouse release with a bigger budget, horror first, franchise second, with a tagline that simply reads “Look fear in the face” across three title cards. Whether general audiences follow a DC logo into an R-rated body-horror film in the same month as every other Halloween release is an open question, and a modest budget is the studio’s hedge against the answer being no.
What the final trailer really settles is tone. The earlier footage made the case that “Clayface” is a horror film about a vain man losing his face, and this one adds the second half of that idea, the moment when losing your face stops being a tragedy and starts being a weapon. If the film lands the turn from victim to predator as well as these hundred seconds suggest, Watkins and Harries may have made the most distinctive thing DC Studios has released so far. We will know on October 23rd, and the trailer has made sure we will walk in without having seen the monster.
What Do You Think? Is keeping Clayface’s final form out of every trailer the smart horror move, or does DC need to show the monster before opening weekend? Does that hug, with hands sinking into Hagen’s back, mean he can absorb people, and how far should an R-rated DC film take that idea? And after the “Is that so bad?” line, are you expecting Hagen to be the film’s victim, its villain, or both?
Catch up properly: every DC movie and show in chronological order on our Timeline Hub’s DC timeline.
See you on the next binge!
