Spider-Man has had more than one Peter Parker on screen, and the name alone never tells you which one you are watching. “Spider-Man: Brand New Day” arrived in U.S. theaters on July 31st, 2026, built around the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s Peter (Tom Holland). It asks a different question from the earlier films. The older question was which Peter you were watching. The new one is who still remembers him.
Here are the three live-action Peters in Sony’s Spider-Man films, the people who change around each one, and what one spell cost the Marvel version. Warning beyond this point there are spoilers for “Spider-Man: No Way Home” and “Spider-Man: Brand New Day”.
The older question was which Peter you were watching.”
Tobey Maguire played Peter in Sam Raimi’s trilogy, which began in 2002. Andrew Garfield played him in Marc Webb’s “The Amazing Spider-Man” in 2012 and its sequel in 2014. Holland’s films are the third series. Sony’s own descriptions show how different the three Peters are. Raimi’s first film introduces a shy student who gains spider-like abilities. Webb’s first introduces a curious and intelligent teenager searching for answers about his past. In “Spider-Man: Homecoming” Holland’s Peter is a high school sophomore trying to prove himself as a hero, with Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) as his reluctant mentor. Each series also built Peter a different circle of people, and those supporting casts are the clearest proof that these are separate worlds.


Holland’s Peter has a longer history than his first film suggests. In June 2017 Holland confirmed a fan theory that the boy in an Iron Man mask at the Stark Expo in “Iron Man 2” was a young Peter Parker. Jon Watts, who directed “Spider-Man: Homecoming”, said the idea came from rewatching the Marvel films. ComicBook.com reports Watts saying the boy was played by Max Favreau, the son of “Iron Man” director Jon Favreau. Slashfilm points out that six years passed between “Iron Man 2” and “Captain America: Civil War”, enough time for that boy to grow into the teenager at the airport fight.
“Spider-Man: No Way Home” is where the three meet. Peter’s identity is already public after a broadcast by Mysterio, and Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch) tries a spell to undo the damage. Peter’s interference breaks it and pulls in people from other universes who know who Spider-Man is. Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield come back as their own Peters, and Time calls them “two different Peter Parkers.” Sony’s own page says the story “intersects the histories of three live-action Spider-Man franchises”, and it lists the villains as Norman Osborn / Green Goblin (Willem Dafoe), Otto Octavius / Doctor Octopus (Alfred Molina), Max Dillon / Electro (Jamie Foxx), Curt Connors / The Lizard (Rhys Ifans) and Flint Marko / Sandman (Thomas Haden Church). Sony says each was pulled from earlier Spider-Man films. Time says Peter realizes the villains are fated to die in their own worlds, so he decides to cure them before sending them home. The three Spider-Men team up against them at the Statue of Liberty.

The people around Peter come in versions too. Aunt May was Rosemary Harris for Raimi, Sally Field for Webb and Marisa Tomei for the Marvel films. Uncle Ben was Cliff Robertson for Raimi and Martin Sheen for Webb. Flash Thompson, the classmate who bullied Peter, was Joe Manganiello, Chris Zylka and Tony Revolori in the same order. Sony names Harry Osborn (James Franco) as Peter’s best friend in Raimi’s first film and calls Ned Leeds (Jacob Batalon) his inseparable best friend in the Marvel films. The love interest changes as well: Mary Jane Watson (Kirsten Dunst) for Raimi, Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone) for Webb and MJ (Zendaya) for Marvel.
Curt Connors is the sharpest case. Dylan Baker played him in Raimi’s “Spider-Man 2” and “Spider-Man 3”, and he never became the Lizard. Baker has said he was supposed to play the Lizard in Raimi’s unmade fourth film. Rhys Ifans played Connors for Webb, and in “The Amazing Spider-Man” an experimental treatment turns him into the Lizard. Same man, two universes, two outcomes. That is what a variant is. In “No Way Home” it is the Ifans version who arrives in Peter’s world.
The film ends with the spell going through, and it makes the whole world forget who Peter Parker is, MJ and Ned included. The villains and the other two Spider-Men go home, so Maguire’s and Garfield’s Peters return to their own universes. Aunt May is already dead by then, killed by the Green Goblin. Sony’s description of the sequel says Peter sacrificed his relationships with MJ and Ned to save the world.
“Brand New Day” picks up four years later. Destin Daniel Cretton directs it from a script by Chris McKenna and Erik Sommers, who wrote “No Way Home” too. Peter has thrown himself into being Spider-Man full time and is being reshaped by loss and isolation. Sony says his greatest challenge may be holding on to the Peter Parker side of his life, because Spider-Man takes up more of his time. MJ is now an MIT graduate with no memory of Peter or the life they shared. Ned has spent the four years at MIT beside her and is preparing to share an apartment with her. He has also built a Spidey Tracker app to follow sightings of Spider-Man. Sony calls the Punisher, Frank Castle, an “unlikely ally and, perhaps, the closest thing Peter Parker has to a friend.” Sony frames his arc as learning the limits of going it alone.
MJ finds a letter Peter wrote her about their shared past, and she confronts him over it. Her memories of him do not come back. Ned is in the same position, and Sony says he does not remember Peter.
The last scene belongs to Ned. Peter goes to buy flowers for Aunt May’s grave and runs into him. Peter introduces himself and the two shake hands, and their old handshake from the “Homecoming” films takes over without a word. Ned says Peter’s name and the film ends. In the closing stretch MJ is also shown on a rooftop, holding the necklace Peter once gave her.
The film leaves the reason open. Looper and CinemaBlend read Ned’s reaction as muscle memory, a habit in his body that outlasted the spell. GamesRadar notes that Strange had said the spell could not be undone. Looper also floats a plainer reading: a name slipped out earlier in the film and raised Ned’s suspicion. Either way, the spell has not done its whole job, because one person now knows who Peter is.
A short post-credits scene shows Ned’s Spidey Tracker picking up Spider-Man’s signal far out in space. Sony’s own FAQ calls “Brand New Day” the last Marvel Cinematic Universe release before “Avengers: Doomsday”. Where Peter goes next is guesswork. Looper suggests he may sit out “Avengers: Doomsday” and return in “Avengers: Secret Wars”. NME assumes he joins the fight against Doctor Doom in one of the two.
That leaves the three Peters in very different places. Maguire’s and Garfield’s went home to their own worlds. Holland’s stayed in a world that no longer knew his name, and “Brand New Day” ends with one friend saying that name aloud again. Whether the spell is broken or only bent is the question the film leaves behind.
What Do You Think? Which Peter Parker feels like the real one: Tobey Maguire’s, Andrew Garfield’s or Tom Holland’s? Did Ned’s handshake break Doctor Strange’s spell or was it only muscle memory? And should Peter sit out “Avengers: Doomsday” while the world still does not know him?
Catch up properly: every MCU movie and show in chronological order on the MCU+ Universe Tree.
See you on the next binge!
