“Tenebrae” is Latin for darkness, and it is also the name of a service in which the candles are put out one at a time until there is nothing left to see by. The Walking Dead: Dead City ended its third season on 13 September with an episode that earns the title twice over, once for the villain it snuffs out and once for the question it leaves burning. Three seasons have circled the same problem: what are Maggie and Negan to each other after he beat her husband to death in front of her. The finale finally answers, and the answer is neither forgiveness nor revenge. Lauren Cohan has described the place they reach through the line Maggie gives him: “You’ve got me. We’re forever connected. We’re chained to one another.”
The episode landed on AMC+ at midnight Pacific and on AMC at 9pm Eastern the same night, closing a season that began on 26 July. Maggie (Lauren Cohan) and Negan (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) are joined by Hershel Rhee (Logan Kim), Luis DeLeon (Raúl Castillo), his sister Renata DeLeon (Aimee Garcia) and the season’s antagonist, Mason Dillard (Jimmi Simpson). Warning beyond this point there are full spoilers for the season three finale, including every major beat, who dies and how, and what the closing scenes set up. If you have not watched it, stop here.
You’ve got me. We’re forever connected. We’re chained to one another.”
The episode opens in flashback to the day the Croat blew the methane tanks, and what it shows is not the explosion but what Dillard was doing while the city burned. He is sitting with his two walkers, Cockenspiel and Titicaca, inside a fantasy where the three of them are a sitcom, complete with canned laughter. It plays as comedy for exactly as long as it takes to realise this is the man’s entire interior life. Then comes the detail that reframes the season: after the blast, Dillard could not see his own face in a mirror, and he only got his reflection back when he put his old NYPD uniform on. He does not see monsters when he looks at the dead. He sees the only company that never left, and he needs a costume to believe he is a person at all.
Then it turns genuinely nasty. Renata did not survive the shot Dillard put in her last week. She died, she turned, and rather than let her lie he has her strapped down and is drawing her teeth and pulling her fingernails, making her “safe” enough to fill a vacant seat in his little family. He does it in front of Luis, her brother, who is tied up and cannot look away. Aimee Garcia spent the season building a community leader worth caring about, and the show kills her between episodes and then uses her body as set dressing. It is the most effective scene in the hour and also the season’s worst instinct, fully visible in one shot. Dillard’s actual plan is aimed at the softest spot he has found: he stakes Luis out in the street as bait, takes over the community speakers, and offers a trade. Negan hands himself over, and everyone else lives.
Negan’s instinct is to take the deal, because after three seasons of being told he is the reason bad things arrive, here is a version of events where he gets to be the payment instead of the debt. Maggie will not let him, and the conversation that follows is the real climax of the season, arriving a good half hour before the fighting stops. She does not forgive him. She is explicit that she never will, and the show never pretends Glenn is a closed file. What she tells him is that forgiveness has stopped being the point, because they have known each other longer than anyone else still breathing and she is not losing another person to make a point. Morgan simply comes apart playing it. It is the best two minutes either actor has had on this show.
What follows is the most competently staged action the series has managed, and it uses all three of them properly. Maggie opens a subway pen and drives a herd into Dillard’s people. Negan gets past the fence by crawling underneath a corpse, then whistles to pull Dillard and a tail of walkers into an empty building. Hershel swings across from a neighbouring roof to warn the residents and kills one of Dillard’s men with a thrown knife, his first human kill, which the show declines to underline. Maggie reaches Luis before his guard can finish the job, and Renata is finally put down during the escape. By The TV Cave’s account of the scene, Maggie hands Luis the knife and lets him do it himself, which is the only moment in the hour that treats Renata as a person rather than a prop.
The confrontation nearly collapses on contrivance and the episode half knows it. Maggie gets a shot off and it does not put Dillard down. One of his own men tries to kill Negan and Dillard stops him, because Negan is his. The two of them end up in a room with their bats lowered, talking, and at one point Dillard asks Negan about a video game. Simpson has called that his favourite beat in the episode, two men who have spent weeks trying to kill each other pausing to work out whether they are actually friends. It is ridiculous, and it works, because the season’s real argument was never that Dillard was violent. It was that nobody ever stayed.
Then he names his price, and it is not Negan’s life. Dillard admits he never wanted to kill him. He wants proof that what he lost was worth nothing, so one of the two people in front of him has to die and Negan gets to choose. Negan puts the knife into Maggie’s abdomen, somewhere he knows will not kill her, and spends the second it buys going straight at Dillard. It is a deliberate mirror of the season two finale, when Maggie stabbed him, and it reads as trust rather than betrayal only because of that conversation half an hour earlier. Dillard wins the fight anyway, gets Lucille up over Negan, and it is Maggie, stabbed and on the floor, who takes his arm off. She is ready to finish him. Negan stops her.
What he does instead is the best idea in the episode. He stays with the man while he bleeds out, and then, rather than putting a blade through his skull, tips him out of a window and lets him turn. A week later Dillard is shuffling down a street with Cockenspiel and Titicaca, no idea who he is, exactly where he always said he was happiest. Simpson has called it an existential sigh of relief, and said that in the final moments Dillard understands the futility of the path he chose. It is a mercy performed by declining to kill. The epilogue is quiet and does a great deal in very little time: Maggie takes off her wedding ring with no dialogue to explain it, Hershel paints a mural of Renata and collects his first year certificate from Luis, and Negan gets an apartment and, from Maggie, Dillard’s old badge and the job of running security.
That badge is the whole series in one prop. A man who once governed by fear is asked to protect a community by a woman who will never forgive him, using a dead man’s authority. Then Maggie points out that Manhattan is one borough of five. Be aware there is no season four yet: not cancelled, not renewed, with no pickup at Comic Con this summer and nothing from AMC since. Showrunner Seth Hoffman speaks strictly in the conditional, saying only that if they are lucky enough to get one he will keep pushing, and that the friction would stop being about Glenn and start being about governing, because the two of them have different worldviews, strategies and tactics. Reviews have split hard, from four out of five and “the best condition the show has ever been in” to one outlet calling it aggressively dumb and asking AMC not to renew. Our read sits nearer the first. This is a finale with real ideas, clumsy plotting around them, and one closing move better than anything the spinoff has done before.
What Do You Think? Was letting Dillard turn the kindest thing Negan has ever done, or a cop out that spared the show from killing him properly? Does Maggie making Glenn’s murderer her head of security read as earned after three seasons, or as the writers picking the fun dynamic over the honest one? And if AMC does greenlight a fourth season, should it head for the other boroughs, or has this story said what it has to say?
Catch up properly: every Walking Dead film, series and special in chronological order on our Timeline Hub’s Walking Dead timeline.
See you on the next binge!
